Comments on: Laya deeply offended by “Munich”

By: Ary

Ary — Wed, 08 Feb 2006 14:55:19 +0000

I actually thought the movie was pretty good.

By: these nuts

these nuts — Mon, 06 Feb 2006 15:09:42 +0000

lets say something else what vrelley touched me in the movie a nice line something like this>>
isreal was not found by isrealis. EXACTLY ISREAL would be toast infact they would not even exists with out my dollars and my weapons who were giving to them and still are, things gonna change ill tell u go let them do their own fucking war
i bet if isreal did not have any support jusst like the arab countrys they would flame them in 2 days with out any hessitation so keep praying to the wall… and by the way movie sucked ass

By: Yas

Yas — Tue, 31 Jan 2006 19:21:59 +0000

Hmmmmm, nominated as of today for “Best film”, “Best Adapted screenplay” and (I think) “Best director”.

By: Yas

Yas — Tue, 31 Jan 2006 19:04:01 +0000

Hmmmmm, nominated as of today for “Best film”, “Best Adapted screenplay” and (I think) “Besti director”.

By: laya

laya — Mon, 30 Jan 2006 09:03:29 +0000

and if your own people convinced you to leave your house, telling you you would reclaim it and more as soon as they wiped another people into the sea, but then they lost the war and continued to exploit your suffering that in a sick and twisted war of propaganda because their manly egos were hurt by defeat… oh, nevermind. The movie still sucked.

By: ck

ck — Mon, 30 Jan 2006 08:15:46 +0000

AH: Come on. Your analogy is both a gross oversimplificaton and a distortion of the Middle East conflict. Can we at least agree that the movie sucked?

By: AH

AH — Mon, 30 Jan 2006 02:11:11 +0000

let us forget the film for a while and think about this:
If someone came and kicked u out of ur home. but u refused so he killed ur father and sister and eventually took ur home and settled in it. What will u do? What will u do?!!!! Yeah, you will live side by side in peace!
this is exactly what Israel have done to the Palestines.
Your sins will come back and hunt u oneday.

By: Fresh

Fresh — Sun, 29 Jan 2006 11:11:36 +0000

A pathetic movie. Must say that ive never been a big fan of Spielberg films.
In Munich he fails to develop characters realistically, many of the scenes look acted are poorly edited and badly shot(im shocked that this film may win an oscar for best film). Sad times for the industry.

Take a movie such as the “City Of G-d” (although a different story altogether) it manages to build real characters with outstanding cinematography and you never want to leave the cinema. I was praying for the Munich to end 30 minutes into the film. A movie like this should never be shot entirely in english. It makes the film feel totally unreal.

Munich had no character and was obviously not researched professionally or extensively. Do you honestly believe an Israeli “hit” team would be so unprofessional and careless. You’re talking about the most sophisticated and well respected intelligence org. in the world and you show them off as amateurs.

I dont know how Spielberg does it. but he manages to get box office hits one after the other and yet in my opinion he is still an amateur.

someone needs to remake this film and show spielberg how it should have been done! i bet half the budget could easily do it!

By: Laya

Laya — Sat, 28 Jan 2006 17:57:05 +0000

taltman – I disagree somewhat. I think most american are sick of the “war on terror” and see the whole Iraqi invasion as a mistake. If they “identify with it, they will probably identify with the futility of the fight, a clear message in Munich.

the “jewish” content seemed overly contrived. I don’t think anyone could miss a room with three huge and prominent menorah. It was like, yes, their Jewish, we get

I really don’t see how its good for Israel, if anything, it makes our best stories be boring.

Ano, not off hand, if i remember some, I’l get back to you.

By: Ephraim

Ephraim — Fri, 27 Jan 2006 22:38:42 +0000

Spielberg should leave the moral heavy lifting to epopel who are better at it and stick with what he's good at. Raiders of the Lost Ark absolutely kicked ass. Tha;s Spielberg's real milieu and he should stay there. Haven't seen Munich, not gonna. Schindler's List, or, should I say, the moralizing and posturing that surrounded it, turned me so off that I've been leery of Spielberg ever since when he's in his mussar mode.. And I know what you mean about all of the "father-son conflicts". War of the Worlds was a classic example. A billion people need to get killed so some snot-nosed punk can realize his father's not a total schmuck? Jesus.